Review: Death’s Lover (The Eternal Lovers, #1) by Marie Hall

Posted on by
Death’s Lover
Paranormal Romance – Fae – Witches
This book may be unsuitable for people under 17 years of age due to its use of sexual content, drug and alcohol use, and/or violence.*

Eve Philips thought she could never love again. After her husband died in a hit-and-run accident, Eve poured her heart into her potions shop, Witch’s Brew, and hasn’t given any man a second glance-until Cian. As soon as she locks eyes with him, Eve knows she’ll never be the same. Gorgeous and mysterious, he incites a passion in her that she’s never felt before. And it’s almost otherworldly . . . 

Cian knows Eve is special the minute they lay eyes on each other. He’s a supernatural being with a dangerous duty, and being seen is not part of the job description. But when he meets the kind, beautiful Eve, all the rules go out the window. Now that his superiors have gotten wind of it, he has a wicked enemy on his tail. Yet all he cares about is Eve: loving her, protecting her-and finding the right time to tell her his dark and terrible secret, a secret that threatens both of their lives . . .

Previously published as The Witching Hour

~ 3.5 Death Stars ~ 

Marie Hall is an amazing writer and story teller. I love her Kingdom series and when I saw the cover and read the blurb for Death’s Lover I was interested. A Grim Reaper (Death) as a leading man sounded appealing. Death’s Lover is book one in Marie Hall’s The Eternal Lovers series.

I enjoyed this story, but not as much as I wanted too. I had a hard time getting into the story/plot at first, but once things settled down, the book took off. Marie brings to us a verity of creatures in Death’s Lover, but our main focus is the Grim Reaper(s) and their future. 

Eve is a witch, who projects powerful magic (emotions). She seams to have no control over projecting her emotions all over the place, but I got the impression that before her husband died she had control. With this aspect we see a vulnerability to Eve we might not have seen. We also see that she is very powerful, but the author does not give us much on this. It would have be nice to have a better understanding of her powers. We see bits and pieces, but only her projection power is understood. 

Cian is Death, the Grim Reaper, but he is not the only Grim Reaper. He’s haunted by his job, numb to feelings, and feels he will never love. He’s been around for a very long time, so some of his old speak seeps in with a little Irish accent. **Sigh** Who doesn’t like an accent? Once he lays eyes on Eve things start to change and when he has to take her soul well something happens to change him. 

The story is told from several perspectives. The transition between points of views where not always immediately clear, but it was nice to see what was going on in everyone’s mind. At the start of the book Eve is married and completely in love, but something happens to change all this. Cian and Eve are both complex characters. Eve’s emotions are very real and at times heartbreaking. Cian battles with himself, his desire to protect Eve and the love growing. Both characters emotions and struggles come across to the reader. With the romance Ms. Hall does a great job building up to those moments in the book. We feel the heat just before an all consuming kiss. At the end I really felt for Cian and his plight. The fae especially the Grim Reaper(s) are hated (it’s not fully explained why?), and somethings are said between Eve and Cian that hurts his feelings. I wanted to smack Eve at that moment when things where revealed and all she could do was the poor me routine. As for the ending, it wasn’t the best.

All and all Death’s Lover is a good read. For some reason it did not give me that great “Ah” moment or fulfillment that I usually get from Ms. Hall, but I am interested to see where the plot is going in The Eternal Lovers series. 


I'm an outdoor sun loving reader living near San Fransisco. I’m a mother, wife, animal & book lover. I'm the owner, reviewer & mind behind Angel’s Guilty Pleasures. My favorite animals are horses & dogs. As for reading I love all things paranormal & urban fantasy & my favorite shifters are dragons.

2 comments on “Review: Death’s Lover (The Eternal Lovers, #1) by Marie Hall

  1. I read “Her mad hatter” a few months ago, I really wanted to love it but somehow there was something missing. Not an awful book, no, but not as great as I hoped it would be. So I get your point 😉 Good review !

    • Hi Red Iza,

      Thank you for stoping bye and enjoy the review. Ya I don’t know it just felt like something was missing, but I could not put my finger on it. I enjoyed it, but never go the wow factor I did in her Kingdom series. Book two is coming out this month in the Eternal Mates series. I’m curious to see if I’ll enjoy it more then book one.